Stephen King is a legendary author known for his compelling storytelling and ability to tap into the fears and anxieties of readers. His books have stood the test of time, with many being adapted into movies, TV shows, and even comic books. However, like any work of fiction, some moments in King’s novels haven’t aged as well as others. Whether due to changes in societal values, technological advancements, or simply the passage of time, certain scenes or themes might seem outdated or problematic to a modern audience. Let’s dive into seven moments in Stephen King’s books that haven’t aged well.
1. The Controversial Scene in “It”
One of the most talked-about moments in Stephen King’s “It” is a controversial scene involving the group of children known as the Losers’ Club. Without going into explicit detail, this scene, which takes place in the sewers, has raised many eyebrows over the years. While King has defended the scene as a metaphor for the loss of innocence, modern readers often find it disturbing and unnecessary. It’s a prime example of a moment that, while perhaps fitting in the context of the book’s publication in 1986, feels out of place in today’s literary landscape.
2. The Use of Racial Slurs in “The Shining”
“The Shining” is one of King’s most famous works, but it’s not without its flaws. The use of racial slurs, particularly in reference to the character Dick Hallorann, can be jarring for contemporary readers. While it’s important to acknowledge that the book was written in a different era, these instances of outdated language can take readers out of the story and make the book feel less timeless. It serves as a reminder of how societal norms have evolved since the book’s publication in 1977.
3. The Depiction of Women in “Carrie”
“Carrie,” Stephen King’s first published novel, is a classic tale of bullying and revenge. However, some aspects of the book’s depiction of women, particularly the character of Margaret White, Carrie’s mother, haven’t aged well. Margaret is portrayed as a fanatical, abusive mother whose extreme religious beliefs lead her to mistreat her daughter. While the character is meant to be a villain, the portrayal of her religious zealotry can feel exaggerated and one-dimensional, which doesn’t resonate as strongly with modern readers who prefer more nuanced characterizations.
4. The Homophobic Undertones in “The Stand”
“The Stand” is often hailed as one of King’s greatest achievements, but it also contains moments that haven’t aged well, particularly regarding its treatment of LGBTQ+ characters. The book includes several instances of homophobic language and stereotypes that, while perhaps reflective of the time it was written, are uncomfortable for modern readers. These moments can detract from the overall impact of the story, making it harder to fully appreciate the novel’s epic scope and complex character dynamics.
5. The Racial Stereotypes in “The Green Mile”
“The Green Mile” is another beloved King novel that has faced criticism for its depiction of race. The character of John Coffey, a black man with supernatural abilities, falls into the “magical negro” trope, a stereotype where a black character exists solely to help the white protagonist. While the character is portrayed with dignity and humanity, the reliance on this outdated trope can be problematic, especially when viewed through a modern lens. It’s a reminder that even well-intentioned depictions can sometimes reinforce harmful stereotypes.
6. The Treatment of Mental Illness in “Misery”
“Misery” is a tense psychological thriller that delves into the mind of an obsessive fan, Annie Wilkes. However, the portrayal of Annie’s mental illness has been criticized for being overly simplistic and stigmatizing. In the book, Annie is depicted as a violent and unstable character whose mental illness is the root cause of her actions. Modern readers and mental health advocates might find this portrayal problematic, as it reinforces negative stereotypes about mental illness. This is a moment in King’s work that could benefit from a more nuanced approach if written today.
7. The Outdated Technology in “Cell”
“Cell,” a novel about a mysterious signal that turns people into mindless killers when they use their cell phones, is a thrilling read. However, the book’s reliance on early 2000s technology makes it feel dated. The premise, while intriguing, is rooted in a specific time when cell phones were relatively new and not as advanced as they are today. Modern readers, accustomed to smartphones and advanced communication technology, might find the plot less believable or engaging, highlighting how quickly technological advancements can render certain story elements obsolete.
Conclusion
Stephen King’s works are a significant part of literary history, and despite some moments that haven’t aged well, his ability to tell captivating stories remains unmatched. These seven examples serve as reminders of how society and culture evolve over time, and how even the most iconic works can reflect the era in which they were created. While these moments might not resonate as strongly with modern audiences, they don’t diminish the overall impact of King’s contributions to the horror genre.
For more such stories and articles, click here.
FAQs
1. Why is the scene in “It” considered controversial?
The scene is controversial due to its explicit nature involving children, which many readers find disturbing and unnecessary.
2. Has Stephen King addressed the problematic aspects of his books?
Yes, King has acknowledged that some elements of his earlier works may not hold up well by today’s standards, and he often encourages readers to view his books within the context of their time.
3. Are there any plans to rewrite or update these books?
Stephen King has not expressed any intentions to rewrite or update his older works, preferring to leave them as they are.
4. How can modern readers approach these problematic moments?
Modern readers can approach these moments with an understanding of the historical and cultural context in which they were written, while also critically engaging with the text.
5. Do these moments affect the overall quality of King’s work?
While these moments may be problematic, they don’t detract from Stephen King’s overall talent as a storyteller. His ability to create compelling narratives remains influential in the literary world.